An
Inconvenient Truth: We Are Eating Our Planet to
Death
Choosing a Plant-food Based Diet Is a Moral
Issue
This is the one
newsletter I hope you will find
worth forwarding to everyone you know.
 |
Have you felt
helpless as the earth warms? As followers of
the McDougall Diet, we have the power to cause
hard-fought changes that will slow global
warming. And it is not too late. Our success
hangs upon whether or not we can convince very
large numbers of people to make the morally
responsible decision to follow a plant-food
based diet. You and I, who already live on
oatmeal, pasta salads, and bean burritos, have
had eating experiences which allow us to see the
world differently. Our friends, family, and
co-workers haven’t a clue—they cannot imagine
life without beefsteak, fried chicken, and
cheese. So, the opportunity is ours to take.
According to the 2006 UN
report, global production of meat and
milk will more than double by 2050. We
cannot let this happen. Our planet is
already being devastated. Long-overdue
changes based on the truth could halve
livestock usage by 2015 |
 |
To become
prepared, there are two things I am asking you
to do: First, watch Al Gore’s documentary,
An Inconvenient Truth, (now on DVD;
Transcript: at
http://www.hokeg.dyndns.org/AITruth.htm),
and then read the introduction (at least) to the
2006 United Nations report, Livestock’s Long
Shadow. Armed with this information you
will be able to make a real difference,
beginning with the people closest to you. Our
mission is to cause a dietary revolution; an
uprising essential for cooling the planet.
“It
means if there is something wrong,
those who have the ability to take
action, have the responsibility to
take action.”
Nicolas Cage
(2004)
From
the movie, National Treasure,
interpreting the meaning of this
sentence from the Declaration of
Independence, “But when a long train
of abuses and usurpations, pursuing
invariably the same Object evinces a
design to reduce them under absolute
Despotism, it is their right, it is
their duty, to throw off such
Government, and to provide new
Guards for their future security.”
|
Global warming is
the most serious challenge facing the human
race. Al Gore’s warnings in An Inconvenient
Truth deserve your urgent attention—this is not
another Y2K or Mad Cow scare—this is the real
thing.
“But how accurate are some of the
scientific claims made in the documentary? In an
attempt to clear the air,
National Geographic
News checked in with Eric Steig, an earth
scientist at the University of Washington in
Seattle, who saw An Inconvenient Truth at a
preview screening. He says the documentary
handles the science well. 'I was looking for
errors,’ he said. ‘But nothing much struck me as
overblown or wrong.’”
Buying a hybrid
car and switching to energy efficient light
bulbs are important, but these actions pale in
consequence compared to the effects we can get
by causing planet-wide, dietary changes.
Present levels of meat- and dairy-eating may
become synonymous with death to our
civilization.
We stand on a precipice—the planet is ours to
save.
Livestock’s Long
Shadow
According to a
report, Livestock’s Long Shadow
–Environmental Issues and Options, released
in November of 2006 from the United Nations Food
and Agriculture Organization, livestock* emerges
as one of the top two or three most significant
contributors to every one of the most serious
environmental problems. (The release of this
report was not covered by any of the major news
outlets, only a few mentions are found on the
Internet.)
*livestock refers
to beef cattle, dairy cattle, chickens, pigs,
and a few other animals domesticated for food
uses.
The UN Report
The
Following Are Some of the Findings from the UN
Report:
Atmospheric Damage
Animal
agriculture is responsible for 18
percent of the world’s greenhouse
gas emissions as measured in CO2
equivalents. By comparison, all
transportation emits 13.5% of the
CO2. In addition to CO2,
environmentally toxic gases produced
by livestock include nitrous oxide,
methane, and ammonia generated from
the animals’ intestines—belching,
flatus, and manure. The report says
“The impact is so severe that it
needs to be addressed with urgency.” |
|
Livestock: |
|
a |
Produces 65 percent
of human-related nitrous oxide,
which has 296 times the Global
Warming Potential (GWP) of CO2. |
|
a |
Accounts for 37 percent of all
human-induced methane (which is 23
times as warming as CO2). |
|
a |
Generates 64 percent of the ammonia,
which contributes to acid rain and
acidification of ecosystems. |
Land Damage |
|
a |
The
total area occupied by grazing
livestock is equivalent to 26
percent of the ice-free terrestrial
surface of the planet. In
addition, the total area dedicated
to producing feed crops for these
animals amounts to 33 percent of the
total arable land. |
|
a |
Clearing forests to create new
pastures is a major source of
deforestation, especially in Latin
America where, for example, some 70
percent of former rainforests in the
Amazon have been turned over to
grazing. The forests are the major
“sinks” for removing the greenhouse
gases from the atmosphere—they
are the “lungs of the
Earth.” |
Water Damage
The
livestock business is among the most
serious users of the earth’s
increasingly scarce water resources;
in addition, contributing to water
pollution,
excessive growth of organisms,
depletion of oxygen, and the
degeneration of coral reefs, among
other things. |
|
a |
The major water-polluting agents are
animal wastes, antibiotics,
hormones, chemicals from tanneries,
fertilizers, and the pesticides used
to spray feed crops. |
|
a |
In the
United States livestock is
responsible for 55 percent of the
erosion and sediment, 37 percent of
the pesticide use, 50 percent of the
antibiotic use, and a third of the
load of nitrogen and phosphorus put
into freshwater sources. |
|
a |
Widespread overgrazing disturbs
water cycles, reducing replenishment
of above and below ground water
resources. Significant amounts of
water are withdrawn for the
production of feed. |
Species Loss |
|
a |
Livestock’s very presence in vast
tracts of land and its demand for
feed crops also contribute to loss
of other plants and animals;
livestock is identified as a culprit
in 15 out of 24 important ecosystems
that are assessed as in decline. The
loss of species is estimated to be
running 50 to 500 times higher than
background rates found in the fossil
record. |
Is Change
Realistic?
Al Gore wants us
to switch to more efficient forms of
transportation, not to give up our cars
overnight. An enthusiastic campaign to reduce
our dependency on livestock would not have as a
primary goal making everyone become vegan
(eliminating all animal foods); but more
realistically, to cut the consumption of meat
and dairy products—say, in half in 8 years.
That could mean something as simple as asking
people following the Western diet to consume on
average two to three times more mashed potatoes
(or other starchy vegetables) daily, instead of
their usual animal-based foods—I believe this is
not too much to request in order to save the
earth!
Al Gore Does
Not Discuss the Role of Food Animals
Not once during
the 96 minute presentation, An Inconvenient
Truth, did Al Gore mention animal foods as a
cause of global warming or suggest any form of
management of livestock as a solution. This
oversight would be similar to not mentioning
cigarette smoking in a discussion of lung
cancer. With all due respect to Al Gore, I must
speculate as to why he ignored this essential
connection. Ignorance could not have been the
reason. Catastrophic damage to our environment
from livestock, especially cattle, has been
recognized for decades. Nor do I believe his
exclusion of this topic was for political
correctness. His documentary is filled with
unrestrained challenges to almost every segment
of business and society. Al Gore is a brave and
honest man, but he has human frailties, too.
Al Gore identified one reason for his leaving
out the livestock connection in his documentary
when he said, “You
know more than a hundred years ago, Upton
Sinclair wrote this: ‘It's difficult to get a
man to understand something if his salary
depends on him not understanding it.’” Al
Gore has been involved in the business of
raising Black Angus cattle for most of his
life. Today quite a
few Angus breeders from around the country are
among his closest friends.
|
Young
Al Gore with Black Angus from the family
farm |
In his
“must see” documentary, An Inconvenient
Truth, Al Gore failed to tell people
that cows, pigs, sheep,
and poultry are a far greater polluters
of the planet earth than are all the
cars, trains, and airplanes.
|
|
To explain the second source of
his blindness to livestock’s role in global
warming, I offer one of my personal quotes,
“People love to hear good news about their bad
habits.” With no intention to offend, I must
point out that Al Gore’s physical appearance
reflects overindulgence in the Western
diet—filled with meat, chicken, seafood, milk,
and cheese. To speak plainly, he cannot see
over his own dinner plate.
Al Gore is
a giant, defending the truth. I am
confident he will not let his personal
life stand in the way of his
mission—whether or not he himself
changes to a plant-food based diet. |
 |
*Contact Al Gore about his oversight on the
global impact of livestock:
The Office of the
Honorable Al Gore
2100 West End Avenue
Suite 620
Nashville, TN 37203
Or call him at
(615) 327-2227
No e-mail address
for Al Gore
At
http://www.algore.com/ you can send a note
through Al Gore to your representatives in
congress. Ask them to help Americans give up
their meat to save the world.
Does Global
Warming Matter Enough?
For forty years I
have believed people would rise up and take
action once they realized that the vast majority
of human sickness and suffering in developed
countries is due to eating animal foods. The
masses have remained quiet. For the past decade
I have witnessed the growing epidemic of
childhood obesity—a misery caused largely by the
fast food giants. All this time I have waited
for informed citizens to rise up in protest, or
at the very least, to boycott the perpetrators
of this child abuse. The sellers of easily
procured beef burgers and milk shakes thrive
uncontested by a single one of us.
Until now,
inaction meant other people and their children
became fat, sick and died prematurely—somehow,
we have been able to live with those
immoralities. The inconvenient truth is that
most human beings find the destruction of fellow
human beings, even little ones, acceptable. You
can assume these same people will sit idly by
and let the entire earth be destroyed. But we
cannot let this happen, because this is our
world, too. This time, failure to act means we
and our children will be lost, along with those
who do not seem to understand or care.
The Reverend Martin Luther King
Jr. warned that “our lives begin to end the day
we become silent about things that matter.”
Nothing matters more than solving global
warming. Those of us—meaning you and I (experts
or not)—who have the ability to take action,
have the responsibility to take action.
Please Help with the Solution
Over the next
month, during every spare moment, think about
this crisis. (I have been able to think of
little else myself recently.) Watch Al Gore’s
DVD, read the UN report, and Noam Mohr’s article
in this newsletter. If you have not done so
already, stop (or reduce) eating meat, poultry,
fish and dairy—ask your family and friends to do
the same and tell them why. Mail your
thoughts to me at
drmcdougall@drmcdougall.com. Next
month’s (January 2007) newsletter will reflect
our collective efforts for meaningful ways to
move forward.
“Everything we need to do to save it
(earth) is something we should be
doing for other reasons anyway. We
have everything we need already to
start saving it with the possible
exception of the will to act. But
in the United States of America that
is a renewable resource.”
Al
Gore’s concluding remarks on the
December 5, 2006 Oprah Winfrey show.
|
|